Surgical reconstruction techniques for irreparable subscapularis tears provide functional improvement but variable...

Irreparable subscapularis tears can cause severe functional impairment and present significant clinical challenges. Current treatment options include tendon transfers (TTs), anterior capsular reconstruction, and reverse shoulder arthroplasty. Each approach has distinct biomechanical advantages and limitations, but there remains no consensus regarding the optimal treatment. This systematic review aimed to evaluate and compare clinical outcomes, failure rates, and complication profiles of surgical reconstruction techniques for irreparable subscapularis tears.

This systematic review followed PRISMA guidelines. A comprehensive search was conducted in Embase, OVID Medline, and Emcare databases. Eligible studies included adults with irreparable subscapularis tears treated with surgical reconstruction (e.g., tendon transfers, graft augmentation, or anterior capsular reconstruction) and reporting clinical outcomes. Methodological quality was assessed using the Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS) score. A narrative synthesis was performed with descriptive statistics (frequencies, percentages, or weighted means with variability).

Fourteen studies comprising 351 patients (355 shoulders) were included, with a mean age of 58.1 years (SD 9.5) and mean follow-up of 44.7 months (SD 54.4). Studied procedures included latissimus dorsi (LD) TT (6 studies, n ​= ​164), pectoralis major (PM) TT (5 studies, n ​= ​94), pectoralis minor (Pm) TT (1 study, n ​= ​74), and anterior capsular reconstruction (ACR; 2 studies, n ​= ​25). PM TT had the highest failure rate (13.0 ​%), followed by ACR (12.0 ​%), LD transfer (11.0 ​%), and Pm TT (1.4 ​%). Postoperative complications were most frequent after PM TT (12.8 ​%), while LD TT had a complication rate of 9.8 ​%. Patient-reported outcome measures improved across all groups, with the greatest Constant-Murley Score (CMS) improvement following LD TT (+33.0), the greatest Subjective Shoulder Value (SSV) improvement after PM TT (+38.6), and the largest Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) pain reduction following ACR (-5.0) and Pm transfer (-5.1).

Surgical reconstruction techniques for irreparable subscapularis tears provide improvements in pain and function, though failure and complication rates vary by procedure and appear worse with concomitant rotator cuff pathology. Further high-quality comparative studies are needed to refine patient selection and optimize surgical decision-making.

IV.