Studying Time-Resolved Functional Connectivity via Communication Theory: On the Complementary Nature of Phase Synchronization and Sliding Window Pearson Correlation

Background: Time-resolved functional network connectivity (trFNC) assesses the time-resolved coupling between brain regions using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data. This study aims to compare two techniques used to estimate trFNC, to investigate their similarities and differences when applied to fMRI data. These techniques are the sliding window Pearson correlation (SWPC), an amplitude-based approach, and phase synchrony (PS), a phase-based technique. Methods: To accomplish our objective, we used resting-state fMRI data from the Human Connectome Project with 827 subjects [repetition time (TR): 0.7 sec] and the Function Biomedical Informatics Research Network with 311 subjects (TR: 2 sec), which included 151 schizophrenia (SZ) patients and 160 controls. Results: Our simulations reveal distinct strengths in two connectivity methods: SWPC captures high-magnitude, low-frequency connectivity, whereas PS detects low-magnitude, high-frequency connectivity. Stronger correlations between SWPC and PS align with pronounced fMRI oscillations. For fMRI data, higher correlations between SWPC and PS occur with matched frequencies and smaller SWPC window sizes (∼30 sec), but larger windows (∼88 sec) sacrifice clinically relevant information. Both methods identify a SZ-associated brain network state but show different patterns: SWPC highlights low anticorrelations between visual, subcortical, auditory, and sensory-motor networks, whereas PS shows reduced positive synchronization among these networks. Conclusion: In sum, our findings underscore the complementary nature of SWPC and PS, elucidating their respective strengths and limitations without implying the superiority of one over the other.