DNA Methylation-Based Classification of Kidney Neoplasms

Renal neoplasms are morphologically and molecularly heterogeneous, with their diagnosis often hindered by interobserver variability and overlapping microscopic features. A subset of cases is unclassifiable despite immunohistochemical, mutation, and cytogenetic-based diagnostic workup. Through examination of the genome-wide DNA methylation signatures of over 2000 renal neoplasms, we identified 23 coherent groups that correlate with known neoplasm types and identified novel clinically relevant subtypes of existing neoplasm types. We used machine learning models to develop and validate a classifier trained on DNA methylation profiles of 1284 samples. The classifier was tested on an external data set of 287 renal neoplasms with >90% concordance between expected neoplasm type and high-score DNA methylation-based classification. Discordance between the original histologic label and methylation class led to potential reclassification of some cases. This work demonstrates proof of principle for the feasibility of a DNA methylation classifier as a clinically useful tool to assist in the diagnosis of renal neoplasms.