Statistical Analysis of Digital 3D Models of a Fossil Tetrapod Skull from µCT and Optical Scanning

The quality of digital 3D models of fossils is important from the perspective of their further usage, either for scientific or didactical purposes. However, fidelity evaluation has rarely been attempted for digitized fossil objects. In the present research, a 3D triangulated model of the unique skull of Madygenerpeton pustulatum was built using an YXLON µCT device. The comparative analysis was performed using models obtained from seven optical surface-scanning systems. Methodology for accuracy assessment involved the determination of distances between the points in pairs of models, interchanging the reference and tested ones. Statistical significance testing using paired t-tests was performed. In particular, it was found that the YXLON µCT model was closest to the one obtained from AICON SmartScan, exhibiting an average distance of ∆d¯ = -0.0183 mm with a standard deviation of σ{∆_d} = 0.0778 mm, which is close to the permissible error of 20 µm given in technical specifications for AICON scanners. It was demonstrated that the analysis maintained measurement validity even though the YXLON model consisted of 23.8 M polygons and the AICON model consisted of 13.9 M polygons. Comparison with other digital models demonstrated that the fidelity of the triangulated µCT model made it feasible for further research and dissemination purposes.