Assessing liquid biopsy tests for the detection of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma: an umbrella review

We conducted an umbrella review to synthesize the evidence on the diagnostic performance of liquid biopsy tests for detection of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). Systematic reviews (SRs) were searched in Medline, Embase, and Google Scholar through December 6, 2023. The Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal Tool for Systematic Reviews was used to assess methodological quality. Two independent reviewers extracted data. We examined the pooled sensitivity and specificity of biomarker classes. We also statistically pooled sensitivity and specificity of individual biomarkers for oral SCC in cases where meta-analysis was not yet published, since most HNSCC occurs in the oral cavity. Performance was also assessed by specimen type (saliva, serum, plasma, and whole blood). Thirty-one SRs met inclusion criteria and 21 included meta-analyses on transcriptomic, proteomic, genomic, or metabolomic biomarkers. Overall methodologic quality was moderate to high. Primary study overlap was ≥ 15 % in 9.3 % of SR pairwise comparisons. MicroRNA (miRNA) was the biomarker class represented in the most SRs (n = 19) and individual studies (n = 106). Among these, the highest sensitivity was 77 % (95 % CI, 68-84 %), observed in miRNA-21. Hypermethylated DNA was the biomarker class with the highest pooled sensitivity (86 %; 95 % CI, 60-96 %) and specificity (92 %; 95 % CI, 80-97 %) overall, and with superior performance when used in panels compared to individual markers. In studies focused on OSCC detection, no other biomarker class or fluid type demonstrated superior performance over others. In future clinical studies, panels including hypermethylated DNA merit more rigorous evaluation to establish high specificity in addition to sufficient sensitivity.