The microbiota elicits compensatory adaptation in a seasonally-adapting animal host

Seasonal adaptation in Drosophila melanogaster is a model for understanding the evolutionary responses of organisms to cyclical environmental changes, including roles played by associated microorganisms ('microbiota'). Here we examined how the microbiota influences D. melanogaster seasonal adaptation by rearing flies in outdoor mesocosms, fed diets inoculated with different bacterial strains that have distinct influences on the flies' life history. The bacterial treatments influenced fly population dynamics and microbiota composition over a summer-to-fall season. The developmental phenotype of the treated flies initially differed but converged over time in flies reared with a complete microbial community. Conversely, rearing the flies free of their colonizing microorganisms revealed that the bacterial treatments led to evolution of distinct developmental phenotypes. The development time of flies from the different treatments consistently adapted to compensate for the direct influence of the bacteria on host development; e.g., flies evolved faster development times if they were inoculated with microbes that slowed development. This compensatory trend was apparent in flies reared in a second location and season, and is consistent with a previous report of wild-sampled flies whose development phenotype segregated with their microbiota composition. Together, these results reveal that microbiota-dependent selection consistently elicits compensatory adaptation in seasonally-evolving flies, which we conclude is a mechanism whereby horizontally-acquired, low-fidelity microbial partners can shape the evolution of their animal hosts.