Implementation outcomes of the IMARA-South Africa mother-daughter HIV/STI prevention intervention: A mixed-methods...

IMARA-South Africa (SA) is an HIV/STI prevention program for adolescent girls and young women (AGYW) and their female caregivers (FC). We examined six implementation outcomes of IMARA-SA (acceptability, appropriateness, feasibility, reach, adoption, and sustainability) from the perspectives of study staff, investigators, and collaborators.

We used a sequential explanatory mixed-methods design. We administered surveys, hosted three focus group discussions with study staff/facilitators (n = 5), clinic staff (n = 3), and community advisory board members (n = 5), and conducted seven key informant interviews with investigators and study staff. We used descriptive statistics and rapid qualitative analyses, merging quantitative and qualitative data by implementation outcome to achieve triangulation.

On 27 surveys analyzed, mean scores were highest for acceptability (2.8/3, SD = 0.6), appropriateness (2.7/3, SD = 0.5), and reach (2.7/3, SD = 0.5), followed by feasibility (2.1/3, SD = 0.5), adoption (3.8/5, SD = 0.3), and sustainability (5.9/7, SD = 0.8). All perceived the AGYW and FC to love the program, which fit well with South African culture and addressed AGYW's needs. The delivery site was deemed highly appropriate for reaching vulnerable populations. The lowest scoring items concerned time constraints (2.2/3, SD = 0.9), safety concerns (1.4/3, SD = 0.7), complexity (2.9/5, SD = 1.3), and cost (2.8/5, SD = 0.9). Qualitative participants attributed complexity and cost challenges to the research procedures, not the intervention. Participants proposed potential avenues for future implementation (e.g., schools, clinics) and interest in engaging males.

IMARA-SA is implementable. Findings reveal challenges with navigating trade-offs between implementation outcomes and surveys distinguishing between intervention and research activities. Findings can inform future delivery of IMARA-SA and similar programs regionally.