Differential Population Responses to White-Nose Syndrome Between Two Michigan Bat Hibernacula Are Not due to...

Disease outcomes result from the interaction between host, pathogen, and environmental factors. Understanding how these components interact to influence spatial and temporal variations in disease severity can enhance our insights into the drivers of disease outbreaks, ultimately improving our ability to mitigate the impact of disease through better forecasts and management actions. White-nose syndrome (WNS) in bats, caused by the fungal pathogen Pseudogymnoascus destructans (Pd), has been detected in hibernating bats across much of the United States and Canada. This pathogen has led to widespread population declines in some bat species, for example, Myotis lucifugus; however, not all infected populations exhibit similar decreases in numbers. Despite long-term detection and high infection levels, the population of M. lucifugus that uses Tippy Dam, in northern Michigan, as a hibernaculum has not experienced a decline compared to other populations in the state. To assess local population effects that may contribute to reduced disease severity at Tippy Dam, we brought 30 hibernating M. lucifugus from Tippy Dam and 30 from a geographically similar hibernaculum with a history of declines from WNS into captivity at the U.S. Geological Survey, National Wildlife Health Center. We challenged the bats with a Pd inoculum and monitored survival, pathology, and Pd loads for up to 120 days. This allowed us to remove local environmental effects that could influence WNS disease severity. We observed no effect of source population on either survival or wing damage from Pd infection. Our results suggest that population persistence and lowered disease severity in Tippy Dam are likely driven by local environmental factors found within the dam. As Pd continues to spread westward, understanding environmental factors that influence the severity of Pd infection in hibernating bats has the potential to guide management decisions and help predict the survival of susceptible bat species in the western United States.