The Need for Standardization of PRAME Immunohistochemistry in Melanocytic Neoplasms

Calla M Sullivan1,2, Dominick DiMaio3, Scott Lauer3

  • 1Department of Dermatology, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE 68198, USA.

Insights

The PRAME immunohistochemistry stain shows poor reproducibility among dermatopathologists for diagnosing melanomas. Further research is needed for a standardized scoring method for PRAME (PReferentially expressed Antigen in MElanoma) interpretation.

Area of Science:

  • Dermatopathology
  • Oncology
  • Immunohistochemistry

Background:

  • Accurate melanoma diagnosis is critical for patient outcomes.
  • PRAME (PReferentially expressed Antigen in MElanoma) is a key immunohistochemical marker for melanoma.
  • Evaluating the reliability of PRAME scoring is essential for clinical practice.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To assess the inter-rater reliability of PRAME scoring among dermatopathologists.
  • To identify challenges in PRAME interpretation for melanocytic neoplasms.
  • To determine the need for improved PRAME scoring methodologies.

Main Methods:

  • A blinded survey of 21 melanocytic neoplasms stained with PRAME and H&E.
  • Five dermatopathologists provided PRAME scores (0-4+), percent positivity, H-score, and interpretation.
  • Statistical analysis using Kappa statistic and intraclass correlations (ICCs) for reliability assessment.

Main Results:

  • Poor inter-rater reliability was observed for PRAME score (Kappa = 0.16).
  • Low reliability was also found for percent PRAME positivity (ICC = 0.31) and H-score (ICC = 0.40).
  • Significant variation in reporting language among pathologists was noted.

Conclusions:

  • PRAME immunohistochemistry interpretation currently lacks sufficient reproducibility, particularly for difficult cases.
  • A more standardized and rigorous scoring system for PRAME is required.
  • Future studies should explore AI for PRAME interpretation to enhance reliability.

Related Concept Videos

Immunocytochemistry and Immunohistochemistry01:22

Immunocytochemistry and Immunohistochemistry

Immunocytochemistry (ICC) and immunohistochemistry (IHC) are techniques that use antibodies to check for specific proteins or antigens in a sample. The technique was first published by Albert Coons in 1941 to detect the presence of pneumococcal antigen in tissue sections from mice infected with Pneumococcus. Immunocytochemistry helps localization of proteins or antigens in individual cells like blood cells, stem cells, etc., while immunohistochemistry does the same for tissue samples.
These...
13.5K
Standard Enthalpy of Formation02:37

Standard Enthalpy of Formation

Enthalpy changes are typically tabulated for reactions in which both the reactants and products are at the same conditions. A standard state is a commonly accepted set of conditions used as a reference point for the determination of properties under other different conditions. For chemists, the IUPAC standard state refers to materials under a pressure of 1 bar and solutions at 1 M and does not specify a temperature. Many thermochemical tables list values with a standard state of 1 atm. Because...
49.0K
Standard Electrode Potentials03:02

Standard Electrode Potentials

On comparing the reactivity of silver and lead, it is observed that the two ionic species, Ag+ (aq) and Pb2+ (aq), show a difference in their redox reactivity towards copper: the silver ion undergoes spontaneous reduction, while the lead ion does not. This relative redox activity can be easily quantified in electrochemical cells by a property called cell potential. This property is commonly known as cell voltage in electrochemistry, and it is a measure of the energy which accompanies the charge...
50.0K
Measurement: Standard Units03:38

Measurement: Standard Units

Every measurement provides three kinds of information: the size or magnitude of the measurement (a number), a standard of comparison for the measurement (a unit), and an indication of the uncertainty of the measurement. While the number and unit are explicitly represented when a quantity is written, the uncertainty is an aspect of the errors in the measurement results.
78.2K
Calculating Standard Free Energy Changes02:49

Calculating Standard Free Energy Changes

The free energy change for a reaction that occurs under the standard conditions of 1 bar pressure and at 298 K is called the standard free energy change. Since free energy is a state function, its value depends only on the conditions of the initial and final states of the system. A convenient and common approach to the calculation of free energy changes for physical and chemical reactions is by use of widely available compilations of standard state thermodynamic data. One method involves the...
24.7K
Standard Solutions01:14

Standard Solutions

Standard solutions refer to solutions with a precisely known concentration or composition. A primary standard is a highly pure, high molar mass, stable substance that is entirely soluble in water, the most commonly used solvent in analytical chemistry. The primary standard solution can be used to standardize secondary standards, which are substances with known concentrations but are less pure and stable. Standard solutions are essential for achieving accurate and reliable results in analytical...
2.3K