Will Nontoxic High-Performance Perovskite Photovoltaics Ever Be Possible?

Lead-based halide perovskite solar cells represent a significant advancement in photovoltaic technology, achieving certified power conversion efficiencies of over 27%. However, the toxicity of lead poses a major barrier to widespread commercialization. The demand for environmentally safe alternatives has driven extensive research into Pb-free perovskites. Current efforts include replacing Pb with Sn or Ge; forming double perovskites in which Pb is substituted by a monovalent-trivalent cation pair; and developing chalcogenide perovskites where the B site (ABX₃) adopts tetravalent cations (rather than Pb) to balance the charge. This concept examines the recent progress in developing Pb-free alternatives, revealing fundamental performance bottlenecks, inherent material limitations, and persistent development challenges. Through a comparative assessment of material properties and device performance limitations, this work highlights the underlying dilemma between environmental safety and efficiency in perovskite photovoltaics. The analysis identifies fundamental material constraints that create substantial barriers to simultaneously achieving both objectives.