Convergent evolution of intestinal lineages in the phylum Methanobacteriota

Representatives of the phylum Methanobacteriota occur in various anoxic environments, but only members of the genera Methanosphaera and Methanobrevibacter exclusively colonize the digestive tract of animals. Recent phylogenomic analyses revealed that the genus Methanobrevibacter, which harbors the majority of the intestinal species, is severely underclassified and represents a family-level taxon, "Methanobrevibacteraceae", that evolved entirely in the digestive tract of animals.

Comparative genome analysis of 158 species of Methanobacteriota, including uncultured representatives in the Genome Taxonomy Database (GTDB), demonstrated that the intestinal lineages are clearly separated from the remaining members of the phylum. They differ from the non-intestinal lineages in genome size, GC content, coding density, an increased number of pseudogenes and adhesin-like proteins, and show numerous adaptations to the copiotrophic gut environment. A decreased biosynthetic potential led to a dependence on other community members and limits the dispersal of intestinal species into other habitats, which is reflected in coevolutionary patterns with their major host groups among arthropods, ungulates, and primates. Certain lineages even engaged in symbiotic associations with intestinal protists, presumably benefiting from the H₂ produced by the hydrogenosomes of their anaerobic hosts.

Our results reveal that the transition of free-living Methanobacteriota to a host-associated lifestyle involves the same genomic changes that were previously recognized in gut bacteria and bacterial endosymbionts of protists, reflecting resemblances between the two prokaryotic domains that are caused by evolutionary convergence in similar environments.