Can preoperative optimization improve abdominal wall surgery outcomes? a qualitative systematic review

Ventral hernia repair (VHR) is commonly performed in patients with multiple modifiable risk factors. Preoperative rehabilitation programs aim to optimize these risk factors and improve surgical outcomes; however, their implementation and effectiveness remain variable. This systematic review evaluates current evidence on the role of preoperative optimization in patients undergoing VHR.

Cochrane Central, Embase, and PubMed were searched for studies comparing preoperative interventions versus standard care in patients undergoing VHR. The primary outcome was characterization of rehabilitation strategies. Secondary outcomes included surgical utilization, emergent repair, readmission, surgical site infection (SSI), surgical site occurrence (SSO), recurrence, reoperation, and mortality.

Six studies were included, comprising a total of 3,556 patients, of whom 1,805 (50.7%) underwent preoperative optimization. Preoperative optimization interventions were highly heterogeneous and primarily consisted of multidisciplinary programs focused on exercise, weight loss, and lifestyle modification. Control groups varied widely, precluding formal meta-analysis. Studies requiring predefined optimization targets reported unsuccessful rehabilitation rates of 5.1%-45%. Emergent repair occurred in 6.8% of intervention patients in one study. SSI rates seemed lower and ranged from 4.2% to 11.8% in intervention groups versus 11.0%-16.7% in controls, SSO and reoperation rates were generally lower in optimization groups.

Structured preoperative optimization pathways may be associated with improved short-term outcomes in select patients undergoing VHR. However, the current literature is heterogeneous, and standardized protocols and prospective studies are needed to better define optimal implementation strategies and long-term effectiveness.