Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 28, 2026

A Protocol for the Administration of Real-Time fMRI Neurofeedback Training
Published on: August 24, 2017
Design and Experimental Investigation of a Multi-Level Heartbeat Sound Feedback-Based Neurofeedback System: Neural
Xiuyan Hu1, Mingge Kang1, Yijing Liu1
1College of Information Engineering, Chinese People's Armed Police Force Engineering University, Xi'an 710086, China.
Abstract:
Auditory neurofeedback training (NFT) based on brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) has recently entered the precision motor domain as a task-embedded neural state regulation paradigm. Compared to traditional standalone NFT approaches (e.g., relaxation or attention training designed to enhance general cognitive abilities), task-embedded paradigms integrate feedback directly into the motor task execution process. However, this design inevitably creates a dual-task scenario, and the effects of such a scenario on neural activity and behavioral performance have received limited systematic investigation in the existing literature. This study designed and implemented a closed-loop BCI system employing five-level heartbeat sound feedback and used this system as a research platform to examine the immediate neural mechanism changes and potential dual-task interference effects induced by single-session auditory NFT in moderately skilled shooters. The system maps real-time EEG features onto graded auditory signals varying in playback rate and volume intensity, incorporating a dynamic threshold adjustment mechanism. Twenty-two moderately skilled shooters completed three within-subject conditions (no-sound baseline, SMR enhancement, and theta suppression) in a single session with 32-channel EEG and behavioral data recorded simultaneously. Analyses employed whole-brain cluster-based permutation tests, cross-frequency coupling analysis, and functional connectivity analysis. Cluster-based permutation tests revealed that theta feedback induced a significant frontal 4-7 Hz suppression cluster (cluster p = 0.004), whereas SMR feedback did not produce significant 12-15 Hz enhancement at the group level. Theta feedback elicited cross-frequency spillover as follows: sensorimotor SMR power decreased significantly in theta responders (d = -0.69), with frontal theta and sensorimotor SMR changes positively correlated (r = 0.67, p < 0.001). Functional connectivity analysis using debiased weighted phase lag index (dwPLI) further demonstrated significant theta-band network reorganization (cluster p = 0.034). At the neural level, clear modulation effects were observed, but shooting ring values did not improve significantly under feedback conditions, and aiming time was significantly prolonged-a behavioral pattern consistent with potential dual-task interference from task-embedded auditory feedback. Single-session auditory NFT can act on the prefrontal cognitive control network and induce cross-frequency network reorganization, but the feedback channel itself constitutes a parallel task that may limit the short-term transfer of induced neural states to behavioral performance. This study examined the neural mechanisms of task-embedded auditory NFT and reported the dual-task costs that have been less characterized in prior "task + feedback" research, providing design considerations and preliminary mechanistic evidence for future development of auditory NFT in precision motor skill training.