Bacteriophage Heteroresistance as a Cause of Treatment Failure in Urinary Tract Infections

With the rise of antimicrobial resistance, urinary tract infections (UTIs) have become increasingly more difficult to treat, prompting renewed interest in bacteriophage (phage) therapy as an alternative or adjunct to antibiotics. UTIs are an attractive target for phage therapy because they generate a high density of actively replicating bacteria that supports phage propagation, and because the urinary tract is readily accessible for administration and monitoring. Yet studies of phage therapy for UTIs report mixed outcomes, including failures to meet clinical and microbiological endpoints. Here we follow the population dynamics of a clinical Escherichia coli UTI strain and two phages, HP3 and ES19, to which the strain appears susceptible by standard testing. Despite this apparent susceptibilty, both phages fail to suppress the strain, with resistance emerging almost immediately. Using the measured mutation rate, our mathematical model shows that traditional resistance cannot account for these dynamics. We instead demonstrate, including by a phage-specific population analysis profile assay we developed, that heteroresistance drives this rapid failure, offering a plausible explanation for treatment failures in UTI phage therapy.