A Cost-Effective High Task Alignment Model for Ultrasound-Guided Central Venous Catheterization Training

Central venous catheterization (CVC) is a fundamental procedural competency in pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM). Although commercially available task trainers are effective for teaching CVC placement, their high cost and logistical requirements can limit access to repeated practice.

To evaluate learner and faculty perceptions and usability of a newly developed CVC simulation model compared with a standard commercial task trainer and detail the technical report of the novel model's construction.

We conducted a prospective educational evaluation during the PCCM CVC workshop. Participants practiced CVC placement with both the standard commercial trainer and a locally constructed simulation model developed at our institution. Teaching faculty were asked to evaluate both models from an instructional standpoint.

Eighteen participants (15 PCCM 1st year fellows and 3 faculty instructors) evaluated the novel CVC simulation model. All fellows (n = 15, 100%) preferred the new model over a standard commercial model, with 14 (93%) reporting improved understanding of CVC insertion steps and 11 (73%) noting ease of ultrasound landmark identification. All fellows (n = 15, 100%) endorsed inclusion of the model in future workshops. Additionally, faculty instructors preferred the novel model for teaching (n = 3, 100%). All faculty supported future use of the model. The initial model development cost was approximately $288.96 with most materials' reusable.

The novel task-aligned CVC simulation model offers a realistic, reusable, and cost-effective alternative to commercial simulators, with high learner and faculty preference and strong educational value. Its functional alignment supports integration into fellowship training, with future studies needed to assess objective skill acquisition and retention.