Divergent C. elegans toxin alleles are suppressed by distinct mechanisms

Toxin-antidote elements (TAs) are selfish DNA sequences that bias their transmission to the next generation. TAs typically consist of two linked genes: a toxin and an antidote. The toxin kills progeny that do not inherit the TA, while the antidote counteracts the toxin in progeny that inherit the TA. We previously discovered two TAs in Caenorhabditis elegans that follow the canonical TA model of two linked genes: peel-1/zeel-1 and sup-35/pha-1. Here, we report a new TA that exists in three distinct states across the C. elegans population. The canonical TA, which is found in isolates from the Hawaiian Islands, consists of two genes that encode a maternally deposited toxin (TMRL-1) and a zygotically expressed antidote (AMRL-1). The toxin induces larval lethality in embryos that do not inherit the antidote gene. A second version of the TA has lost the toxin gene but retains a partially functional antidote. Most C. elegans isolates, including the standard laboratory strain N2, carry a highly divergent allele of the toxin that has retained its activity, but have lost the antidote through pseudogenization. Multiple lines of evidence suggest that the N2 tmrl-1 allele is likely recognized by piRNAs, leading to MUT-16-dependent 22G small interfering RNA (siRNA) production and post-transcriptional silencing of the transcript. The N2 haplotype represents the first naturally occurring unlinked toxin-antidote system where the toxin is post-transcriptionally suppressed by endogenous small RNA pathways.