Shared genetic basis and structure of syndromic and normal facial variation

The question of how gene mutations of large effect and common variants of small effect relate to phenotypic variation dates from the origins of genetics. Mendelian diseases result from rare germline variants with major effects, while complex traits are associated with multiple, mostly common variants of small effect. High-dimensional phenotypes, such as facial shape, can shed new light on this age-old dichotomy, as their variation can be characterized in terms of directions in multivariate morphospace. Within such spaces, do Mendelian disease mutations move phenotypes along the same directions as common variants, or do they forge new directions that diverge from the common structure of background variation? Here, we analyze facial shape variation for 66 syndromes, quantify multivariate axes of facial shape variation for each syndrome, and test whether common genetic variants in cohorts of non-syndromic subjects are associated with phenotypic position along these same axes. We find that syndromic facial shape generally follows the background variance-covariance structure of facial shape in the general population. Furthermore, syndromic probands' unaffected relatives have subtle facial morphology resembling the syndromes of their affected relatives. These results suggest that Mendelian disease variants act on facial shape in ways similar to common variants. Syndromic probands with higher "severity" likely occur on genetic backgrounds with higher cumulative severity of common variants for each syndromic axis. These findings position Mendelian diseases at extremes along phenotypic continua that exist in the background population rather than as qualitatively different phenotypes distinct from the overall structure of normal human phenotypic variation.