Related Experiment Video
Updated: Oct 10, 2026

Multimedia Battery for Assessment of Cognitive and Basic Skills in Mathematics (BM-PROMA)
Published on: August 28, 2021
Mathematics-Writing Assessments: An Analysis of Prompts and Scoring Methods on Performance of Students With and
Tessa L Arsenault1, Sarah R Powell2, Kayla Garvais2
1The University of Texas at El Paso, USA.
Abstract:
Mathematics writing occurs regularly in classroom instruction, on state assessments, and as part of research. Yet, little research measures how student outcomes may differ across mathematics-writing prompt structures and scoring methods. We examined how students with and without mathematics difficulty (MD) performed across mathematics-writing prompt structures (i.e., problem-solving steps and problem-solving response method) and scoring methods (i.e., holistic and elements rubrics). We sampled 375 Grade 4 students with and without MD. Each student completed one of four mathematics-writing prompts. These prompts differed by problem-solving steps and problem-solving response method. Students without MD significantly outperformed students with MD on prompts with pseudo-student work for the elements rubric. In addition, students' measured performance differed across holistic and elements rubrics. In conclusion, performance trends for all students differed across the prompts and rubrics, demonstrating a need for careful consideration when selecting mathematics-writing prompts and rubrics.
Related Concept Videos
Learning Disabilities
Dyslexia
Dyslexia is a...
Mathematical Modeling: Problem Solving
Inequalities
Optimization Problems
Reliability and Validity
Geometric Mean
In cases of multiplicative data, the geometric mean is used for statistical analysis. First, the product of all the elements is taken. Then, if there are n elements in the...

