Airway deadspace, end-tidal CO2, and Christian Bohr

In order to calculate alveolar deadspace, an important measure of ventilation/perfusion mismatching, it is necessary to measure airway or anatomical deadspace (VDaw) and physiological deadspace. VDaw is usually measured graphically or by similar means, but sometimes it is estimated from a formula, based on Christian Bohr's work, in which end-tidal PCO2 is used as a measure of alveolar PCO2. In 58 patients undergoing anaesthesia and positive pressure ventilation, there were large errors in this estimate of VDaw compared to a graphical method. At tidal volumes of 400-500 ml, the median error was 34 ml; at larger tidal volumes, the median error increased to 74 ml (P less than 0.001). The size of the error was correlated to the slope of phase III, the part of the CO2 tracing representing alveolar CO2, at both ventilator settings (P less than 0.01). It is concluded that estimates of VDaw based on end-tidal PCO2 are unreliable, and their use will lead to a large part of the alveolar deadspace being wrongly accredited to VDaw.