The absence of the Ives effect in a deuteranope

Ives found that when monochromatic stimuli are matched to white by flicker photometry, they are not equal in brightness to the white by direct comparison, and the discrepancy is minimal for yellow but is increased for longer and shorter wavelengths. On the two sides of yellow, the colors are more saturated, and Ives postulated that brightness involves the sum of a chromatic component and an achromatic component and that the chromatic component varies with the saturation. In the case of a deuteranope, one would expect a vigorous chromatic response for yellow and blue stimuli but a poor response for the neutral part of the spectrum. The Ives effect is virtually nonexistent for subject SR, who is a deuteranope. In terms of the zone theory of color vision, this would mean that the blue-yellow chromatic channel contributes little or nothing to brightness. In a normal observer, the blue-yellow mechanism can be isolated by using blues and yellows depurified with white, but in this case the Ives effect is found to exist.