Assessment of fertilization failure and abnormal fertilization after intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)

The assessment of fertilization is an important part of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) and oocytes are routinely examined about 17 h after injection using Nomarski differential interference contrast optics. However, it is not possible to conclusively determine the aetiology of fertilization anomalies in this manner, so cytological studies were undertaken to determine the causes of failed and abnormal fertilization after ICSI. Oocytes which exhibited no evidence of fertilization, one pronucleus (PN) or 3 PN were fixed in glutaraldehyde, stained with Hoechst 33342 and examined by fluorescence microscopy to identify PN, metaphase chromosomes, sperm heads and polar bodies. A total of 428 unfertilized oocytes were examined from 170 ICSI cycles. Overall, 82% of these unfertilized oocytes were still at metaphase II (non-activated) while the remaining 18% were activated and had 1 PN and two polar bodies. The majority (71%) of the metaphase II oocytes contained a swollen sperm head, which indicates that the spermatozoon was correctly injected but the oocyte did not activate and complete its second meiotic division. The swollen sperm head was located among the metaphase chromosomes in 4.3% of these oocytes, while in some cases (6.6%), the sperm chromosomes had undergone premature chromosome condensation (PCC). Other aetiologies of failed fertilization in these metaphase oocytes were ejection of the spermatozoon from the oocyte (19%) and complete failure of sperm head decondensation (10%). A similar pattern of anomalies was found in 1 PN oocytes, although the ratios were different (swollen sperm head, 51%; ejection of the spermatozoon, 19%; undecondensed sperm head, 30%). Seventy abnormally fertilized oocytes were also examined, of which 63 had 3 PN and a single polar body, indicating that the unextruded second polar body developed into the third PN. In conclusion, the present study demonstrates that the principal cause of fertilization failure after ICSI is failure of oocyte activation and not ejection of the spermatozoon from the oocyte. It is also apparent that further studies are needed to elucidate the mechanisms that control oocyte activation and sperm head decondensation in injected oocytes.