Comparison of fresh and glutaraldehyde-treated autologous stented pericardium as pulmonary valve replacement

The use of fresh autologous pericardium in valve surgery has shown poor results in the past mainly due to thickening and retraction. Recently, it has been suggested that a short treatment with glutaraldehyde might radically change its behavior. In an attempt to determine whether this disparity in results is due to the glutaraldehyde treatment or to a better present-day surgical technique, fresh and glutaraldehyde-treated autologous pericardium was mounted in a frame and implanted in the pulmonary position of adult sheep. Six survivors obtained in each group were sacrificed between 2 and 8 months in the "fresh" group and between 2 and 6 months in the "glutaraldehyde-treated" group. Macroscopically, the fresh pericardium became thickened and retracted in all specimens, eventually resulting in severe regurgitation, while the glutaraldehyde-treated, although slightly thickened, retained its pliability without significant retraction. Microscopically, viability of the central core of the collagen was more often preserved in the fresh pericardium. Endothelialization was irregular. In conclusion, short glutaraldehyde treatment seems to improve the results of autologous pericardium mounted on a valve stent. Its effect on calcification remains to be ascertained.