CTL escape viral variants. II. Biologic activity in vivo

The proteins of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) contain only three known peptide regions that are processed and then held in place by the MHC class I H-2b (Db) glycoprotein on the cell's surface for recognition by LCMV-specific Db-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). These peptides are from the glycoprotein (GP), amino acids 33-41 KAVYNFATC (GP1) and 276-286 SGVENPGGYCL (GP2), and the nucleoprotein (NP), 396-404. We have used CTL clones that recognized only GP1, GP2, and NP to select viral variants that upon infecting cells bearing H-2b molecules escaped recognition by virus-specific CTL directed against the viral GP (GP1 + GP2) mutant, termed GPV, or the viral GP and NP (GP1 + GP2 + NP) mutant, termed GPV+NPV. These CTL "escape" variants nevertheless elicited sufficient host-protective activity in vivo to abort acute infection and prevent the occurrence of persistent infection. This protection was CD8+ lymphocyte mediated and associated with the generation of a novel (for H-2b mice) CTL response to the viral L protein. Hence CTL epitopes form a hierarchy, in which responses to "weak" epitopes are suppressed in the presence of "stronger" epitopes. Mutation in the strong epitopes may be of limited biological significance since the host can mount a protective response directed against the second level (weak) epitopes.