Evaluation of protein 3-D structure prediction: comparison of modelled and X-ray structure of an alkaline serine...

We describe the modelling of the structure of the highly alkaline subtilisin protease OPTICLEAN from Bacillus alcalophilus. The model was developed through modelling by homology. We used the structure of subtilisin Carlsberg from the Brookhaven protein databank (entry 1CSE) as start structure. Amino acid changes and deletions were performed with the graphic protein design program BRAGI. Force field calculations and molecular dynamic simulations were made with AMBER 3.0 on a Multiflow TRACE 14/300. The comparison of the model and the later solved X-ray structure of OPTICLEAN shows a high similarity between the two structures, but there were also remarkable deviations between the two structures in some loop regions. The comparison shows that the deviations are due to difficulties in the prediction of correct main chain torsion angles of the prolines and the selection of correct loops in deletion or insertion regions. Strategies to avoid these mistakes are discussed.