Determination and comparison of heat exchange efficiency of four commercially available blood cardioplegia sets

An in vitro comparison of the heat exchange properties of the Electromedics D1081A, Sarns MP-4 'Conducer Coil' 165720, Bentley HE-100 and the Shiley BCD Plus 4: 1 blood cardioplegia sets was performed. The efficiency was calculated for each heat exchanger and post-heat exchange blood path temperatures were compared. The calculated efficiency for each heat exchanger is as follows: Electromedics D1081A at 18 l/minute coil water flow (0.95); Sarns MP-4 165720 at 9 l/minute coil water flow (0.93); Bentley HE-100 at 10 l/minute coil water flow (0.91); Shiley BCD Plus at 15 l/minute coil water flow (0.90). Blood path, precoil temperatures for each unit were compared statistically with no differences found (p > 0.05). Blood side, postcoil temperatures were then compared. The average postcoil blood path temperature of the Electromedics D1081A was 1.6 degrees +/- 0.1 degree C, of the Sarns MP-4 165720 it was 2.1 degrees +/- 0.1 degree C, of the Bentley HE-100 it was 2.7 degrees +/- 0.3 degree C, and the Shiley BCD Plus 3.0 degrees +/- 0.4 degree C. The results of this experiment indicate that the average postcoil temperature of the Electromedics D1081A was lower than the Sarns MP-4 165720 (p < 0.05) which was lower than that of the Bentley HE-100 (p < 0.05) and Shiley BCD Plus (p < 0.05). No statistical difference was found between the average postcoil temperature of the Bentley HE-100 and the Shiley BDC Plus.