Perception of apparent motion between dissimilar gratings: spatiotemporal properties

What determines the strength of texture-defined apparent motion perception when the stimulus has no net directional energy in the Fourier domain? In a previous paper [Werkhoven, Sperling & Chubb (1993) Vision Research, 33, 463-485] we demonstrated the counterintuitive finding that the correspondence in spatial frequency and in modulation amplitude between neighboring patches of texture in a spatiotemporal motion path are irrelevant to motion strength. Instead, we found strong support for what we call a single channel or one-dimensional motion computation: a simple nonlinear transformation of the image, followed by standard motion analysis. Here, we further studied the dimensionality of the motion computation in a parameter space that includes texture orientation and stimulus display rate in addition to texture spatial frequency and modulation amplitude. We used ambiguous motion displays in which one motion path, consisting of patches of nonsimilar texture, competes with another motion path comprised entirely of similar texture patches. The data show that motion between dissimilar patches of texture that are orthogonally oriented, have a two octave difference in spatial frequency and differ 50% in modulation amplitude can easily dominate motion between similar patches of texture. A single channel accounts for more than 70% of texture-from-motion strength for the parameter space examined and this channel is invariant for stimulus display rates varying over a four-fold range.