Patterns of failure in carcinoma of the upper esophagus after alternating chemoradiotherapy

Alternating chemoradiotherapy has recently been reported to produce encouraging results in patients with advanced head and neck cancer. We have treated 17 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the upper esophagus by alternating chemoradiotherapy and by following the patients for 2 to 5 years, or until their death. Chemotherapy (cisplatin and 5-fluorouracil) was delivered during weeks 1, 4, and 7, and radiotherapy (180 to 200 cGy twice each day to 2,000 cGy) during weeks 2, 5, and 8 (total 6,000 cGy). Three patients (18%) died of toxicity (nadir sepsis). All 14 patients who survived the treatment achieved a complete response as shown by endoscopy and biopsy specimens, with restoration of swallowing, and none experienced a local relapse. Three patients died of distant metastases (actuarial incidence 32% at 3 years). The 5-year survival rate was only 16%, however, because 8 other patients with no evidence of the cancer died of a variety of other causes: radiation pneumonitis (1), chronic neutropenia (1), esophageal actinomycosis (1), pneumonia (2), stroke (1), myocardial infarction (1), and small-cell lung cancer (1). Conceivably, some further improvement in the results might occur from cytokines, stem cells, and brachytherapy (by decreasing deaths due to toxicity), but with so many causes of comorbidity it seems unlikely, for the foreseeable future, that the 5-year survival rate could be much improved by better treatment of esophageal cancer.