Initial in vitro stability of the tibial component in a canine model of cementless total knee replacement

The tibial component of a canine cementless total knee replacement model was used to determine the degree to which pegs and screws contributed to the initial in vitro stability of the device. Three implant designs were investigated: (1) a four-peg implant in which cortical bone screws passed through the pegs, (2) the four-peg implant without adjuvant screw fixation, and (3) a flat implant with screws placed in the same positions as in the first design. For measuring the interface motion, the tibial component and proximal tibia were modeled as rigid bodies and an experimental method was developed which permitted all six degrees of freedom of the motion between these two objects to be determined. In tests performed to validate this methodological approach, the potential confounding influences of tibial deformation and differential amounts of tibial deformation with the use of screws or pegs were shown to be minimal, supporting the use of the rigid-body method. In general, the areas of greatest motion were at the periphery of the bone-implant interface, regardless of whether or not screws or pegs were used. The components secured with screws had up to five-fold reductions in interface motion compared to components which had pegs but lacked screw fixation. Components with pegs and screws and components with screws only had the same amount of interface motion. Thus, in the presence of screw fixation, the addition of pegs did not increase the stability of the tibial component.