Zaidel's model of interhemispheric dynamics: empirical tests, a critical appraisal, and a proposed revision

Zaidel has proposed a model of intra- and interhemispheric dynamics which attempts to explain field and hand effects in visual reaction time experiments. The model includes prototypes of two extreme cases: a "callosal relay" pattern, in which interhemispheric transfer is inferred, and a "direct access" pattern, in which each hemisphere is inferred to execute the task independently. Five visual reaction time experiments were carried out to test six predictions which Zaidel has made within the framework of his model. Some of these predictions were supported but others were rejected. These findings, in conjunction with findings of other researchers, were critically analyzed in view of determining the extent to which Zaidel's model can be revised in order to fit the ensemble of relevant findings. It was concluded that the model can indeed be revised but that this requires a redefinition of conditions indicative of presence or absence of interhemispheric relay. A new model is proposed assuming exclusively excitatory callosal relay and focussing on magnitude and valence of field effects obtained at each hand, considered in their interrelation.