On alternatives to selection-induced mutation in the Bgl operon of Escherichia coli

Selection-induced mutations are nonrandom mutations that occur as specific and direct responses to environmental challenge. Examples of selection-induced mutations have been reported both in bacteria and in yeast. I previously showed (Hall 1988) that excisions of the mobile genetic element IS150 from within bglF are selection induced and argued that they occurred because they were potentially advantageous under the selective conditions employed. Mittler and Lenski (Mittler and Lenski 1992) have argued that such excisions are not selection induced but that they occur randomly in nondividing cells. Here I provide further evidence that IS150 excisions are induced by selection and that the excisions are immediately, rather than only potentially, advantageous to the cell. I also provide evidence that excisions, which Mittler and Lenski claim occur randomly in saturated broth cultures, actually occur after samples from those cultures are plated onto selective medium.