Differential requirement for autoantibody-producing B cells for induction of lymphocytic versus granulomatous...

Mouse thyroglobulin (MTg)-sensitized spleen cells activated in vitro with MTG transfer experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) in which the thyroid cellular infiltrate consists primarily of mononuclear cells (lymphocytic EAT). Addition of anti-IL2R antibody to cultures with MTg leads to activation of cells that induce granulomatous EAT, accompanied by high serum anti-MTg autoantibody responses, in recipient mice. CD4+ T cells are required to induce both forms of EAT; whether B cells and/or autoantibodies produced by MTg-sensitized B cells also contribute to disease severity or the type of thyroid histopathology is unknown. In our study, B cells and autoantibody responses produced in recipient mice were reduced either by column removal of B cells from donor spleen cells or by treatment of recipient mice with anti-I-AK mAb at the time of cell transfer. These maneuvers only slightly reduced the severity of lymphocytic EAT but markedly reduced the severity and incidence of granulomatous EAT developing in recipient mice. Delaying the initiation of anti-I-AK treatment until 6 days after cell transfer was less effective in reducing anti-MTg autoantibody responses or granulomatous EAT. These studies all suggested that anti-MTg autoantibodies were required for development of granulomatous but not lymphocytic EAT. However anti-I-AK-treated recipients receiving injections of anti-MTg antibody or having serum antibody induced by prior immunization with MTg and LPS also developed less severe granulomatous EAT than controls. These results suggest that sensitized CD4+ T cells and circulating anti-MTg autoantibody are not sufficient for development of granulomatous thyroid lesions. It is possible that antibodies having a unique function or specificity are produced in mice developing granulomatous EAT or thyroid-infiltrating B cells may directly contribute to the granulomatous inflammatory response.