Comparing steady counterflow separation with differential chromatography

Separation of closely related solutes by steady solid-fluid counterflow is compared with differential separation in a fixed chromatographic bed. Analogous expressions for exit concentration and mean residence time in the two systems are presented. A counterpart to chromatographic resolution is derived for binary steady counterflow separations. Estimated counterflow savings in product-concentration dilution, solvent volume requirement and solid-phase volume requirement obtained with these expressions relative to comparable chromatographic operations are compared with experimental results from adsorptive, simulated moving beds. Analysis of a size-exclusion protein separation suggests counterflow substantially decreases solvent and resin usage relative to conventional, batch operation.