Linking medical needs and performance goals: clinical and laboratory perspectives on thyroid disease

Diagnosis and management of thyroid disease benefit substantially from close interactions between clinicians and laboratorians. Clinicians desire reliable tests for diagnosis and management of both hypothyroidism and thyrotoxicosis. Traditionally, multitiered testing has been used, beginning with an index of free thyroxine concentration, which, if abnormal, has been followed by basal thyrotropin (TSH) measurements (for hypothyroidism) or thyrotropin-releasing hormone-stimulated TSH measurements (for thyrotoxicosis). Improvements in analytical methods for TSH have made it practical to use basal TSH measurements in serum as the first-line test for thyroid disease. However, performance guidelines are needed, because not all TSH assays work well in this role. The performance guidelines developed by the American Thyroid Association are reviewed to illustrate how they help to assure consistent analytical testing. Further improvements in TSH assays (third- and fourth-generation assays), which support measurements down to 0.01 mlU/L and 0.001 mIU/L, may provide additional advantages for classifying thyrotoxic patients and monitoring thyroxine-suppressive therapy in patients with thyroid cancer. The potential advantages of these newer assays are illustrated with case examples. Additional analytical performance monitors are proposed to help ensure that these next-generation TSH assays meet the expanded clinical needs.