Collaborating outside the box: when employers and providers take on environmental barriers to guideline...

In 1992 15 employers in Minneapolis/St Paul, operating as the Business Health Care Action Group (BHCAG), combined their self-insured plans. To successfully bid for the BHCAG contract, three competing group practices and a health plan cooperated, operating functionally like a fully integrated care system to measure outcomes, develop practice guidelines, and meet other BHCAG requirements. To accomplish this, a new organization, the Institute for Clinical Systems Integration (ICSI), was conceived. PROVIDERS AND EMPLOYERS COLLABORATE: To reduce costs ICSI has implemented 16 of 80 planned guidelines. Teams including members from clinics and BHCAG develop best-practice algorithms. Each guideline is then reviewed and piloted before being implemented in all ICSI clinics.

The guideline on cystitis in healthy women eliminated two costly practices-obtaining a urine culture and visiting the doctor. Yet many physicians and the clinics were afraid of losing significant revenue because they were reimbursed by BHCAG on a fee-for-service basis. In turn, BHCAG's hands were tied. If they changed to a capitated payment system, they would face onerous state insurance requirements. The solution lay in collaborating at a higher level. ICSI and BHCAG leaders persuaded the state legislature to pass a new law that allowed BHCAG to capitate providers without state regulation. As a result, the cystitis guideline is now widely implemented in ICSI clinics.

The cystitis guideline experience highlights the need to manage the external environment so that it reinforces, rather than inhibits, quality improvement in medical practices. Guidelines will not be implemented unless the macro-environment into which they are introduced is supportive.