Comparison of guinea-pig, bovine and rat alpha 1-adrenoceptor subtypes

1. To elucidate a possible role of species differences in the classification of alpha 1-adrenoceptor subtypes, we have characterized the alpha 1-adrenoceptors in guinea-pig spleen, kidney and cerebral cortex and in bovine cerebral cortex using concentration-dependent alkylation by chloroethylclonidine and competitive binding with 5-methlurapidil, methoxamine, (+)-niguldipine, noradrenaline, oxymetazoline, phentolamine, SDZ NVI-085, tamsulosin and (+)-tamsulosin. Rat liver alpha 1B-adrenoceptors were studied for comparison. Chloroethylclonidine-sensitivity and (+)-niguldipine affinity were also compared at cloned rat and bovine alpha 1a-adrenoceptors. 2. Chloroethylclonidine concentration-dependently inactivated alpha 1-adrenoceptors in all five tissues. While chloroethylclonidine inactivated almost all alpha 1-adrenoceptors in rat liver and guinea-pig kidney and brain, 20-30% of alpha 1-adrenoceptors in guinea-pig spleen and bovine brain were resistant to alkylation by 10 microM chloroethylclonidine. With regard to concentration-dependency guinea-pig kidney and brain were approximately 10 fold less sensitive than guinea-pig spleen or rat liver. 3. In rat liver, all drugs tested competed for [3H]-prazosin binding with steep and monophasic curves. Drug affinities were relatively low and resembled most closely those of cloned rat alpha 1b-adrenoceptors. 4. In guinea-pig spleen, all drugs tested competed for [3H]-prazosin binding with steep and monophasic curves. Drug affinities were relatively low and resembled most closely those of cloned rat alpha 1b-adrenoceptors. 5. In guinea-pig kidney most drugs tested competed for [3H]-prazosin binding with steep and monophasic curves and had relatively low drug affinities close to those of cloned rat alpha 1b- and alpha 1d-adrenoceptors. However, noradrenaline and tamsulosin had consistently biphasic competition curves recognizing 36-39% high and 61-64% low affinity sites. 6. In guinea-pig cerebral cortex, all drugs tested competed for [3H]-prazosin binding with shallow and biphasic curves. While most drugs recognized approximately 25% high affinity sites, tamsulosin and noradrenaline recognized approximately 50% high affinity sites. Drug affinities at the high and low affinity sites except those for tamsulosin and noradrenaline resembled those at cloned alpha 1a- and alpha 1b-adrenoceptors, respectively. 7. In bovine cerebral cortex all drugs tested except for noradrenaline competed for [3H]-prazosin binding with shallow and biphasic curves. All drugs recognized approximately 70% high affinity sites. Drug affinities at the high and low affinity sites resembled those at cloned alpha 1a- and alpha 1b-adrenoceptors, respectively. Noradrenaline competition curves in bovine cerebral cortex were steep and monophasic. 8. When cloned rat and bovine alpha 1a-adrenoceptors transiently expressed in COS cells were studied in a direct side-by-side comparison, both species homologues had similar chloroethylclonidine-sensitivity and (+)-niguldipine affinity. 9. We conclude that properties of bovine alpha 1A- and alpha 1B-adrenoceptors are very similar to those of other species such as rat. alpha 1-Adrenoceptor subtypes in guinea-pigs resemble alpha 1A- and alpha 1B-adrenoceptors in other species but chloroethylclonidine sensitivity and competition binding profiles of noradrenaline and tamsulosin are not compatible with previously established alpha 1-adrenoceptor subtype classification.