Experimental and clinical results of fiberoptic argon laser stapedotomy

Since 1992 a small air-cooled opthalmological argon laser (Argus system, 3 W max.) equipped with a fiberoptic microhandpiece has been used for stapedotomy at the Inselspital, Berne. The microhandpiece has been developed especially for otological purposes in our electronic laboratory. In order to measure the effect of argon laser pulses applied through the handpiece to the ear, we performed temperature measurements in a saline-filled inner ear model by using ultrathin (2 microns thick), ultrafast (4 ns) thermosensitive rhodamine-coated polyurethane films. Multiple laser pulses of 1-2.5 W and 0.1 s duration - as used in clinical applications - produced a temperature elevation of about 1 degree C in the liquid of the inner ear model. The local laser effect was then examined histologically on the isolated stapes. The thermal damage zone around the stapedotomy perforation was limited to about 100 microns. In a clinical study we compared the results of argon laser stapedotomy (n = 54) with those of a skeeter microdrill stapedotomy (n = 29). Substantial hearing gains were found in all cases in both groups. In the laser stapedotomy group the mean residual air-bone gap (0.5-2 kHz) was 10 dB or less in all cases but one. Inner ear function remained unchanged except for a 40-dB loss at 4000 Hz in one case. Transient vertigo with nystagmus occurred in one case. Facial nerve dysfunction did not occur in any patient. The most important advantage of the laser found was the absence of mechanical trauma to the stapes. Stapes luxation and a floating footplate were avoided. In contrast, thick footplates were more easily perforated with the skeeter. Use of an argon laser equipped with a fiberoptic microhandpiece and a skeeter microdrill as needed seems particularly advantageous for stapedotomy.