Epithelial ovarian tumors of borderline malignancy

Epithelial ovarian tumors of borderline malignancy are different from benign tumors and malignant neoplasms. They exist with relatively benign clinical course, younger age and better prognosis as compared with invasive malignant carcinomas. Most of them are discovered at early stage, for example, stage Ia. This retrospective review evaluates the clinical features, treatments and prognosis of 48 patients with borderline malignancy of ovarian tumors.

Forty-eight patients with ovarian tumors of borderline malignancy, aged from 14 to 69 years (mean: 39.2 years; median: 36 years), were retrospectively studied. The histopathologic diagnosis was based on the morphologic criteria published by Tazelaar et al. in 1985. All cases, including 16 cases diagnosed before 1985, were pathologically reviewed. All information of clinical stage, surgical intervention and prognosis was achieved by reviewing hospital record or contacting patients by telephone. Two patients were lost to follow up. One patient died of sepsis resulting from another operation for another gynecological cancer. Totally forty-five patients were included for evaluation.

Thirty-nine of the 48 patients (81.3%) were at stage Ia, 6 cases (12.5%) were at stage Ib, 2 cases (4.1%) were at stage Ic, and the remaining one patient (2.1%) was at state IIIc. Thirty-four patients (71%) were with mucinous cystadenoma of borderline malignancy, 11 cases (23%) were of serous type, and 3 patients (6%) were of mixed serous and mucinous type. Twenty-two patients underwent total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (TAH and BSO), but one of them remained partial ovary due to young age (27 y/o). Twelve patients were treated with unilateral oophorectomy or unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (USO). Twelve patients underwent USO and wedge resection of contralateral ovary. One case underwent debulking surgery. One patient underwent enucleation of ovarian tumor and biopsy of contralateral ovary. Eighteen patients were treated with chemotherapy after operation. One patient developed recurrence 4 months after the primary operation. Excluding two cases lost to follow up and one case with surgical mortality for another gynecological cancer, forty-five patients were alive and were followed from 9 months to 165 months. (median: 48 months; mean: 46 months)

Most of the patients were at the early stage of disease when first diagnosed, 81.3% were at stage Ia and only one case was at stage IIIc. Sixty-three percent of our patients underwent surgical treatment alone while the rest of them (37%) had post-operative chemotherapy with either alkeran or PAC. The use of adjuvant chemotherapy seemed unwarranted as there was no difference in survival between those with and without it. (P > 0.05) The low recurrent rate of 2% in our patients again confirmed the 9 P relative benign clinical course of this disease.