Development of human fetal kidney in obstructive uropathy: correlations with ultrasonography and urine biochemistry

In utero urethral obstruction results in bilateral hydronephrosis and severe fetal and post-natal morbidity and mortality. Obstetrical management depends on the indirect evaluation of fetal renal function by ultrasonography and biochemical analysis. No direct evaluation of the severity and possible reversibility of renal lesions is available. In this paper we analyzed kidneys from 34 fetuses (14 to 37 gestational weeks) in which (1) isolated bilateral urinary tract obstruction had been detected in utero by sonography, and (2) the severity of sonographic and biochemical prognostic indicators led to the indication of termination of pregnancy or to perinatal death. Pure hydronephrosis was observed in two young fetuses [14 and 20 gestational weeks (GW)] and was associated with regressive changes in two others. In contrast, a wide spectrum of dysplastic renal lesions was present in 30 fetuses and was classified into four subgroups according to the association of dysplasia, hypoplasia and cysts. They had the following characteristics in common: (1) premature cessation of nephrogenesis assessed by the medullary ray counting method; (2) early disappearance or myofibroblastic differentiation of metanephric blastema; (3) early increase in interstitial mesenchyme with widespread expression of alpha-smooth muscle actin by mesenchymal cells; (4) frequent absence of classical criteria of dysplasia (nests of cartilage were observed in only 5 fetuses); (5) an identification, based upon the detection of alpha-smooth muscle actin expression, of the muscular phenotype of mesenchymal cells encircling primitive ducts. In conclusion, (1) the value of prognostic markers in fetuses less than 20 GW should be reconsidered; (2) after 20 GW there is a good correlation between markers predicting poor prognosis and the severity of renal lesions; (3) hypoplasia with disappearance of blastema cells, dysplasia and early interstitial fibrosis are evidence of the irreversibility of renal lesions and preclude any possibility of new nephron formation; (4) these findings suggest that most surgical in utero procedures are performed when irreversible renal lesions have developed.