Related Experiment Videos
Requests for "inappropriate" treatment based on religious beliefs
1Loma Linda University Medical Center, California.
Journal of Medical Ethics
|June 1, 1997
Summary
Patients' religious beliefs often drive requests for "inappropriate" medical treatments. Clinicians should respect these beliefs, engage in open discussion, and often honor such requests, especially from Abrahamic faiths.
Area of Science:
- Medical Ethics
- Religious Studies
Background:
- Increasing patient/family requests for treatments physicians deem inappropriate.
- Requests often stem from religious beliefs regarding God's attributes, sanctity of life, and personal faith.
Observation:
- Presents four case studies illustrating patient requests for "inappropriate" treatment.
- Analyzes religious tenets from Abrahamic traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) influencing these requests.
Findings:
- Religious reasons for "inappropriate" treatment requests are "special" and warrant careful consideration.
- Understanding patient/surrogate religious beliefs and utilizing religious interpreters is crucial.
- Open dialogue about clinical and theological aspects is recommended.
Implications:
- Clinicians and ethicists need guidance to navigate these complex ethical conflicts.
- Balancing clinical judgment with theological considerations is essential.
- Most persistent requests for "inappropriate" treatment should be honored.