Determination of mean particle volume, a Monte Carlo simulation

Either length measurements or area measurements may be made on a sample of profiles for the purpose of estimating the mean volume of a population of convex particles. Diameters of spheres, caliper diameters of ellipsoids and intercept lengths are available length measurements. Profile areas can be evaluated by planimetry or point counting. Either all the available profiles in random sections or point sampled profiles can be utilized. We have applied a Monte Carlo simulation to compare several of the stereologic methods for the estimation of the mean volumes of spheres and ellipsoids. Populations of spherical, prolate ellipsoidal and oblate ellipsoidal particles were subjected to random sectioning and measurement. Diameter, point sampled intercept length, area and point sampled area were measured in the case of the spherical particles. With the ellipsoids, the same measurement excepting diameters were performed. The measurements were converted to volumes by the appropriate equations, and the means, the standard deviations of the means and the 95% confidence intervals were determined for increasing sample sizes. All the methods provide estimates that converge on their theoretical mean volumes. The area measurements and particularly the point sampled area measurement show some advantage over the length measurements, but differences among the methods are small, not entirely consistent over the different cases and unlikely to be significant in most real applications.