Mechanical performance of polyurethane ureteral stents in vitro and ex vivo

A serious problem associated with the use of ureteral stents is fracture in situ. Following clinical observations of fracture of polyurethane stents in vivo, this study examined the mechanical properties of 17 polyurethane stents (double-J containing drainage holes) retrieved from patients over a 24-week period of insertion. In addition, stents were immersed in human and artificial urine in an in vitro model at 37 degrees C to determine their general propensity to fracture. Mechanical properties of ureteral stents were examined using the standard ASTM D-412 tensile test and by the novel application of dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA). The ultimate tensile strength and elongation at break (but not the Young's modulus) of unused polyurethane stent sections containing side-drainage holes were greater than stent sections devoid of side-drainage holes. No correlations were observed between increased or decreased Young's modulus, ultimate tensile strength or elongation at break of polyurethane stents and their time of immersion in either human urine or artificial urine in simulated upper urinary tract conditions of 37 degrees C and 5% CO2. Similarly, no correlations were observed between Young's modulus, ultimate tensile strength or elongation of polyurethane stents and stent dwell time in situ. DMA of retrieved stents revealed that their tan delta value and storage modulus did not differ significantly from unused stents following dwell times in situ of up to 24 weeks. No changes in the glass transition temperatures were observed in retrieved stents. Although patient variation was observed, the results indicate that the polyurethane stents examined in vitro and following removal from patients did not exhibit any greater propensity to fracture than their unused counterparts. Fracture of retrieved polyurethane stents, arising in vivo and also during subsequent tensile testing, was observed to occur along the drainage holes, suggesting that elimination of these holes will reduce the incidence of polyurethane ureteral stent fracture in use.