Affinities and selectivities of divalent cation binding sites within an RNA tertiary structure

A 58 nucleotide fragment of Escherichia coli large subunit ribosomal RNA, nucleotides 1051 to 1108, adopts a specific tertiary structure normally requiring both monovalent (NH4+ or K+) and divalent (Mg2+) ions to fold; this ion-dependent structure is a prerequisite for recognition by ribosomal protein L11. Melting experiments have been used to show that a sequence variant of this fragment, GACG RNA, is able to adopt a stable tertiary structure in the presence of 1.6 M NH4Cl and absence of divalent ions. The similarity of this high-salt structure to the tertiary structure formed under more typical salt conditions (0.1 M NH4Cl and several mM MgCl2) was shown by its following properties: (i) an unusual ratio of hyperchromicity at 260 nm and 280 nm upon unfolding, (ii) selectivity for NH4+ over K+ or Na+, (iii) stabilization by L11 protein, and (iv) further stabilization by added Mg2+. Delocalized electrostatic interactions of divalent ions with nucleic acids should be very weak in the presence of >1 M monovalent salt; thus stabilization of the tertiary structure by low (<1 mM) Mg2+ concentrations in these high-salt conditions suggests that Mg2+ binds at specific site(s). GACG RNA tertiary structure unfolding in 1.6 M NH4Cl (Tm approximately 39 degrees C) is distinct from melting of the secondary structure (centered at approximately 72 degrees C), and it has been possible to calculate the free energy of tertiary structure stabilization upon addition of various divalent cations. From these binding free energies, ion-RNA binding isotherms for Mn2+, Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+ and Ba2+ have been obtained. All of these ions bind at two sites: one site favors Mg2+ and Ba2+ and discriminates against Ca2+, while the other site favors binding of smaller ions over larger ones (Mg2+ >Ca2+ >Sr2+ >Ba2+). Weak cooperative or anticooperative interactions between the sites, also dependent on ion radius, may also be taking place.