Critical issues in the evolving management of rectal cancer

Evolving trends in the management of rectal cancer have focused on organ preservation, improved quality of life, and survival of patients. A significant shift is underway in our thinking about what constitutes the true rectum and defining the "proximal" and "distal" segments of the rectum. Tumor mobility remains a dominant prognostic factor in patient selection and choice of surgery. A clinical staging with tumor location in the rectum provides a logical algorithm for treatment decision making with either chemoradiation therapy or surgery as initial treatment of choice. Current rectal cancer management has largely focused on postoperative adjuvant radiation strategies with improvement reported for T3 and N+ cases. Recent data from Europe suggests that preoperative radiation has a significant advantage over surgery alone or postoperative treatment. This appears to be borne out by institutional studies of high-dose preoperative radiation (>45 Gy) in the United States. Aggressive preoperative combined chemoradiation has also led to significant downstaging of cancer with pathological complete response rates of 20% to 30%. This offers new options for surgical management of residual disease with endocavitary radiation or local excision. The development of new agents Gemcitabine, paclitaxel, and CPT-11 may also prove beneficial. New treatment strategies need to be coordinated with evolving knowledge of the biological behavior of the tumor based on its genetic fingerprints. c-Ki-ras and C-myc mutations have been implicated in tumor initiation and progression. A number of other tumor suppressor genes, APC gene, p53, and DCC have also been implicated in colorectal tumor carcigenesis. The modification of biological behavior by mutations in these genes is currently under study. This may guide new treatment strategies significantly reducing the death rates from rectal cancer and improving functional results of treatment.