Prognosis for patients with pneumonectomy or lesser resections for non-small cell lung cancer based on histologic...

Contrary results have been reported regarding prognosis by histologic cell type in surgical treatment for lung cancer. To evaluate whether histologic cell type has influence on prognosis, we separately analyzed the prognostic outcome of patients who had undergone pneumonectomy (n=119) and lesser resections (n=124) for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) between January, 1985 and March, 1996. The pneumonectomy group included 87 (73%) squamous cell carcinoma (Sq), 25 (21%) adenocarcinoma (Ad) and 7 other types with 10 (8%) patients in postoperative stage I of the disease, 29 (24%) stage II, 74 (62%) stage III and 6 in stage IV. The lesser resection group included 45 (36%) Sq, 63 (51%) Ad and 16 other types with 71 (57%) patients in stage I, 9 (7%) stage II, 32 (26%) stage III and 12 stage IV. In patients with stages I-III, the 5-year survival rate was 42.8% for the Sq group and 41.1% for the Ad group in the case of lesser resections and 37.1% for the Sq group and 0% for the Ad group (p<0.05) in the case of pneumonectomy. The poorer prognosis for patients with Ad in the case of pneumonectomy was suspected to be due to the N factor; the percentage of patients with N0-1 was significantly lower in the Ad group than for the Sq group (28 vs 62%, p<0.005). Histologic cell type can be a prognostic factor for patients undergoing surgical treatments for NSCLC. One possible reason for the contrary results on prognosis by histologic cell type among investigators may be due to the mixed results of pneumonectomy and lesser resections.