Vaginal birth after cesarean delivery: results in 310 pregnancies

To assess and compare the risk associated with a trial of vaginal birth after cesarean section (VBAC) with the risk of an elective repeat cesarean section.

A retrospective review of the records of 310 consecutive women who, at the Jichi Medical School Hospital in the 6-year period of 1990 through 1995, had previously undergone a primary cesarean section and gave birth to a singleton infant weighing > or = 2,000 g at > or = 36 weeks of gestation in a subsequent pregnancy.

Elective cesarean sections were performed on 96 (31%) of 310 women, and VBACs were attempted by 214 women (69%). Vaginal deliveries were successful in 132 (43%) of the 310 pregnancies. No maternal death or perinatal deaths occurred in either group. A uterine rupture occurred in 2 (0.9%) of the 214 women who attempted a VBAC, and 5 women (2.3%) gave birth to neonates with a 1-minute Apgar score < or = 6. None of the 96 women who underwent an elective cesarean section had such complications, although the difference in these complication rates did not reach a significant level.

A trial of a VBAC significantly reduced the rate of cesarean sections. Although the rates of uterine rupture and neonatal asphyxia were slightly higher in women who attempted a VBAC than in women who underwent an elective cesarean section, obstetricians should offer the option of a trial of labor, because more than one-half of the women with a previous cesarean delivery might have successful vaginal deliveries, and the VBAC-related maternal mortality rate does not reportedly differ between women undergoing a trial of labor and women undergoing an elective repeat cesarean section.