Single toxin detection is inadequate to diagnose Clostridium difficile diarrhea in pediatric patients

Clostridium difficile is an important cause of symptomatic diarrhea in pediatric patients. The bacterium produces two toxins, although many laboratories assay for only one. We questioned this diagnostic approach when patients had positive results for C. difficile at our institution, but initially had tested negative at outside laboratories.

We retrospectively analyzed relative frequencies of C. difficile toxin A alone, toxin B alone, and toxins A and B from pediatric patients with diarrhea. Results were stratified according to toxin detection and patient age.

Of 1061 specimens, 276 (26.8%) were positive for C. difficile toxin(s). Fifty-one (18.5%) were positive for toxin A alone, 133 (48.2%) for toxin B alone, and 92 (33.3%) for both toxins. Assaying for toxin B identified C. difficile infection more frequently than did assaying for toxin A (P < 0.0001). The frequency of toxin B detection was significantly higher for older children but not for infants.

Testing for C. difficile toxin A or toxin B alone will result in more frequent misdiagnosis than testing for both toxins. This practice may lead to inappropriate further invasive investigations in children, although this finding may not be applicable to adults.