[Valproic acid relieved marked rigidity in three patients with end-stage parkinsonism]

We applied valproic acid (VPA) on the rigidity of three parkinsonian patients, two with Parkinson disease and one with striatonigral degeneration. They were all at Hoehn and Yahr's stage V and showed marked rigidity. In these patients, effect of L-DOPA had become limited or increasing the dosage of L-DOPA was difficult because of its side effects. Parkinsonian symptoms were assessed by using motor score of Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale. The degree of rigidity in these three patients was markedly decreased with 300-600 mg/day of VPA. The blood level of VPA ranged from 24.8 to 66.5 micrograms/ml, which was relatively low compared with the effective blood level as an anti-epileptic agent. Parkinsonian symptoms other than rigidity, and the increased deep tendon reflexes which were present in the patient with striatonigral degeneration were not affected by VPA. Reduction of L-DOPA intensified rigidity again which had been under control. Trials of VPA on parkinsonism have been reported from two groups (Price PA, et al. 1978; Nutt J, et al. 1979), neither of which has observed any benefit of VPA. The difference of their results and ours seems to depend on the stage of patients; their patients had mild to moderate symptoms, whereas ours were in the end stage with marked rigidity. Since the effect of VPA upon parkinsonism is limited to rigidity, the end-stage patients whose care is difficult due to severe rigidity may obtain the best benefit of VPA. VPA is considered to take effect by activating gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) system. Because GABA is a common inhibitory neurotransmitter distributed in the wide areas of the central nervous system, it is difficult to locate the action site of VPA with regard to the amelioration of rigidity. The stretch reflex loop in the spinal cord does not seem to be the action site because no change was noted in deep tendon reflex. GABAergic striatal efferent neurons do not seem to be the sole action site either, because parkinsonian symptoms were not affected except for rigidity. The vestibular nucleus which receives strong GABAergic afferents from cerebellar Purkinje cells is an efficient tonus regulator. Since suppression of the function of the nucleus is known to reduce rigidity, it is at least a candidate for the action site of VPA. But there is no direct evidence for this matter. The exact action site of VPA remains to be elucidated.