Search research articles

ABOUT JoVE

Overview Leadership Blog JoVE Help Center

AUTHORS

Publishing Process Editorial Board Scope & Policies Peer Review FAQ Submit

LIBRARIANS

Testimonials Subscriptions Access Resources Library Advisory Board FAQ

RESEARCH

JoVE Journal Methods Collections JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments Archive

EDUCATION

JoVE Core JoVE Business JoVE Science Education JoVE Lab Manual Faculty Resource Center Faculty Site

Terms & Conditions of Use

Search research articles

Related Experiment Videos

[Cabanis before the guillotine].

Histoire Des Sciences Medicales

|October 20, 2001

Summary

This summary is machine-generated.

Cabanis physiologically supported the guillotine despite moral objections, reflecting a humanist practitioner's conflict during the French Revolution. This ambivalence stemmed from his role representing the Paris Hospitals Commission during the device's initial testing.

Related Concept Videos

You might also read

Related Articles

Articles linked to this work by shared authors, journal, and citation graph.

Sort by

Same author

[Savages].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2001

Same author

[G. W. Leibniz: medicine and the sciences of life: 2nd part: Leibniz as a "biologist"].

Histoire des sciences medicales·1996

Same author

[You said Pinel?].

Histoire des sciences medicales·1996

Same author

[G. W. Leibniz: medicine and the sciences of life. Ist part: Leibniz as a "medical practioner].

Histoire des sciences medicales·1995

Same author

[Not Available].

Frenesie·1989

Same author

[Not Available].

Frenesie·1988

Same journal

[Not Available].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2018

Same journal

[Cancer and literature].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2018

Same journal

[Lung diseases and miscellaneous pathologies in the novels of François Mauriac and Pierre Benoit].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2018

Same journal

[Pierre and François Mauriac, a privileged friendship between brothers].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2018

Same journal

[Post traumatic stress during World War I and literature].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2018

Same journal

[Boris Vian and his failed meetings with cardiology].

Histoire des sciences medicales·2018

See all related articles

Area of Science:

Medical Humanities
History of Medicine
Physiology

Background:

Jean-Nicolas Cabanis's "Year IV" essay controversially discusses the guillotine.
The essay presents a physiological defense of the device, contrasting with its political and moral condemnation.
This perspective emerged during a period of intense political upheaval and medical examination of execution methods.

Discussion:

Cabanis's physiological arguments for the guillotine are examined in contrast to his strong political and moral opposition.
The text explores the ethical paradoxes faced by a humanist physician involved in the practical application of a controversial execution device.
The role of key figures like Louis, Guillotine, and Pinel in the guillotine's early use and testing is contextualized.

Key Insights:

Related Experiment Videos

The study highlights Cabanis's complex and ambivalent stance on the guillotine, rooted in both scientific reasoning and ethical concerns.
It reveals the tension between physiological understanding and moral judgment in the context of revolutionary France.
The abstract underscores the psychological burden on medical professionals tasked with evaluating or overseeing instruments of state-sanctioned violence.

Outlook:

Further research could explore the long-term impact of such physiological justifications on medical ethics.
Comparative analyses of other physicians' views during the French Revolution may offer broader insights.
Investigating the reception and influence of Cabanis's essay could illuminate contemporary debates on science, morality, and state power.