Anterior cervical fusion using porous hydroxyapatite ceramics for cervical disc herniation. a two-year follow-up

The Smith-Robinson Method (SR), which employs autogenous bone, is the current standard for anterior cervical fusion (AF) surgery. However, autogenous bone has graft-related complications and morbidity, and harvesting it increases trauma and risk to the patient. The use of hydroxyapatite ceramic (HAP) inserts may provide a superior alternative.

To determine the efficacy of using HAP in AF.

A retrospective study of patients who had AF surgery with wide decompression and porous HAP inserts used to treat cervical disc herniation (CHD).

We evaluated 36 patients who had single-level AF using HAP for CHD, without internal fixations, clinically and radiographically with a minimum follow-up of 2 years. There were 25 men and 11 women, with an average age of 49 years (age range, 24-78 years). Preoperative diagnosis included 25 cases with myelopathy and 11 cases with radiculopathy.

We established four grades to classify the degree of bony fusion between the HAP and vertebra, based on any motion at the fused segment, any radiolucent zones (RZ) between vertebral bodies and the grafted HAP, and anterior or posterior bone formations on grafted HAPs. We evaluated the severity of myelopathy by applying the Japan Orthopaedic Association (JOA) scoring system. We evaluated the surgical outcome of the myelopathy patients using the Hirabayashi recovery rating, and for the radiculopathy patients, we used the Herkowitz criteria.

We retrospectively reviewed the radiographic and clinical records of all 36 patients from surgery up to periods ranging from 2 to 7 years after surgery, with the average period of follow-up being 4.5 years. We systematically classified the degree of bony fusion into four grades ranging from Grade 1 nonunion to Grade 4 complete union.

None of the subjects showed Grades 1 and 2 fusion. Eleven percent of the cases showed Grade 3 and 89% showed Grade 4. Loss of height of the fused segment was observed in 29 cases with an average of 1.6 mm. A decrease of lordotic angle of the fused segment was observed in six cases with an average of 2.3 degrees. Four cases revealed cracked HAP inserts but achieved Grade 4 bone fusion. There was no evidence of collapse or displacement of HAPs. The results of the 11 radiculopathy patients were excellent in 10 cases and good in the remaining case. The recovery rate of the 25 myelopathy patients was 73.0%.

Our method of anterior cervical fusion surgery using porous HAP inserted into resected end plates, combined with a wide decompression procedure, had clinical and radiographic results so satisfactory that we conclude that it can effectively replace the use of autogenous bone for treating cervical disc herniation.