Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of substrate interaction with cobalt substituted alcohol dehydrogenase from liver

The role of zinc in liver alcohol dehydrogenase has been studied by replacement of 1.3 and 3.5 of the four Zn(II) ions with Co(II) and measuring the effects of the paramagnetic Co(II) on the relaxation rates of the protons of water, ethanol, and isobutyramide. Water relaxation studies at 8, 24, 100, and 220 MHz indicate two classes of bound Co(II). The similar to 2 readily replaced Co(II) ions retain one fast exchanging water proton in their inner coordination spheres, while the similar to 2 slowly exchanging Co(II) ions coordinate no detectable water protons, indicating that the former replaced Zn(II) at the "catalytic sites" and the latter replaced Zn(II) at the "structural sites" detected crystallographically. Ethanol, acetaldehyde, and isobutyramide bind with appropriate affinities to the Co(II) substituted alcohol dehydrogenases decreasing the number of fast exchanging protons at the catalytic Co(II) site by greater than or equal to 54 percent. Coenzyme binding causes smaller changes in the water relaxation rate which may be due to local conformation changes. The paramagnetic effects of Co(II) at the catalytic site on the relaxation rates of the methyl protons of isobutyramide at 100 and 220 MHz indicate that this analog binds at a site 9.1 A from the catalytic Co(II). This distance decreases to 6.9 A when NADH is bound, and a Co(II) to methyne proton distance of 6.6 A is determined indicating a conformation change leading to the formation of a second sphere enzyme-Co(II)-isobutyramide complex in which a hydroxyl or water ligand intervenes between the metal and the substrate analog. Similar behavior is observed in the enzyme-ethanol complexes. The paramagnetic effects of Co(II), at the catalytic site, on the relaxation rates of the protons of ethanol at 100 and 220 MHz, indicate that this substrate bind at a site 12-14 A distant from the catalytic Co(II) but that this distancedecreases to 6.3 A in the abortive enzyme-NADH-ethanol complex. The role of the catalytic Co(II) thus appears to be the activation of a hydroxyl or water ligand which polarizes the aldehyde carbonyl group by hydrogen bonding. The role of the structural Co(II), which is more distant from isobutyramide (9-11 A), may be that of a template for protein conformation changes. By combining the present distances with those from previous magnetic resonance studies on the liver enzyme, the arrangement of coenzyme, metal, and substrate at the active site in solution can be constructed. This arrangement is consistent with that of ADP-ribose and zinc in the crystalline complex of liver alcohol dehydrogenase as determined by X-ray crystallography (Branden et al., (1973), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.70, 2439).